COMMENTARY: Digital or
Hard-Copy Scrapbooks?
The New York Times article described below presents an
ominous, depressing view of the future of scrapbook retailing:
consumers will buy printers and software rather than paper and
stickers. Scrapping on a computer takes less time and requires less
space, and makes it easy to copy albums for relatives or share
online it's the perfect solution, right? It better not be.
What about the inks and papers used in printers; are they
acid/lignin free? Saving an album on a CD how long will the CD
last? Will the future generations' computers be able to read today's
digital scrapbook?
Rather than bury our heads in the sand, we need to deal with
digital scrapbooking and know how to talk to our consumers.
So here's the plan: I'm asking all of you involved in
scrapbooking to give me reasons why "hard copy" scrapbooks
are better than the computer versions. Email me your thoughts; I'll
compile them and publish them so retailers will have "talking
points" for consumers who ask, "Why don't I just make a
scrapbook online?" Email your thoughts to mike@clnonline.com.
NEW COLUMNS THIS ISSUE
Scene
& Heard. A report on the recent Society of Decorative
Painters convention/show in Nashville.
Tech
Topics. How women scrappers and crafters both
have changed technology and how it's marketed to consumers.
TAKE THE CLN POLL: THE FIRST HALF OF 2006
Can the year be half over already? Yes, for better or worse. How
is your business compared to the first half of 2005 and what do you
expect for the second half? To vote, click on Industry Polls in the
right-hand column or click HERE.
CLN
POLL: HEALTH INSURANCE
WOES
More than half the respondents in CLN's unscientific poll,
53.9%, said health insurance was a "very serious" issue
for their business. Another 34.6% said the issue was
"serious." Only 3.9% thought it was "not very
serious" while 7.7% didn't know.
Less than half the respondents, 44.4%, provide some or all
employees with insurance, but 57.1% of those have had to reduce
their insurance plans or require employees to pay more.
SHOW NEWS: PAINT, NEEDLEWORK, BEADS, & MEMORY
PAINTING. The 34th convention/show sponsored by
the Society of Decorative Painters in Nashville showed a
significant increase in attendance, although no final figures were
available. For more, visit www.clnonline.com
and click on Scene & Heard in the left-hand column.
TNNA. Given the number of recent complaints about yarn
sales, the show in Indianapolis was a pleasant surprise much more
positive than expected. Publishers, especially those who staged
author book signings such as Interweave, did very well. Needlepoint
seems to be holding its own.
The most important long-term news is the Int. Needlework
Retailers Guild
voted to dissolve at the end of INRG's fiscal year and TNNA
approved bylaws changes to create a Retail Section, whose chair will
be a voting member on the TNNA board. The current INRG Retail Board
Members will be part of the transition team (along with current TNNA
Regional Directors) for the first year. They will help define focus
areas and responsibilities and recommend committee structure within
the Retail Section.
BEADS. Although no final numbers were available for the Bead
& Button show in Milwaukee that ended yesterday, the size of
the sold-out show and the attendance appeared about the same as last
year 16,000 jewelry-makers, retailers, and consumers. Trends:
large beads, the vintage and ethnic/natural looks, lamp work, Swarovski crystals, bead making, and using leather, fibers, and
ribbon.
SCRAPBOOKS. The consensus on the TwoPeas message board was
that the Great American Scrapbook Convention in Arlington, TX
was an excellent show, but smaller and the attendance was down. One
theory: the number of scrapbook shows in Texas may have diluted the
crowd. One vendor was selling everything in his booth for $1. (Note:
That may get rid of excess inventory, but it surely doesn't help
the sales of area independent stores.)
More than 1,800 class tickets were sold online and 24 classes
sold out before the Memories Expo in Somerset, NJ opened. A.C.
Moore sponsored Tim Holtz to demo Ranger Industries inks in its
booth and hosted the Friday and Saturday pajama-themed Creative Bash
Crop Parties. Bash make-it/take-it projects were provided by EK
Success, Epson, Me & My Big Ideas, Provo Craft, Ranger
Industries and Xyron.
(Note: Consumers hunting for bargains were apparent at
both shows. If the shows inspire consumers to increase their
scrapping, then the shows will ultimately help area retailers. If
they are used by exhibitors simply to unload overstocks, then
ultimately area independent stores will be hurt.)
CRAFTRENDS, CREATING KEEPSAKES
SOLD
Primedia has agreed to sell substantially all of the assets
of its Crafts Group to Enthusiast Media, an entity controlled
by affiliates of Sandler Capital Management, for $132 million,
subject to audit adjustments. The deal is expected to close in the
third quarter.
The sale includes 10 magazines and their affiliated events,
including the MemoryTrends and Creating Keepsakes Universities and
Conventions. The magazines are Craftrends, Creating Keepsakes,
Simple Scrapbooks, Paper Crafts, McCall's Quilting, McCall's Quick Quilts, Quilter's Newsletter Magazine,
Quiltmaker, Sew
News, and Creative Machine Embroidery. Step by Step Beads is not
included.
The company will operate as a stand-alone LLC under the temporary
name of
Enthusiast Media. Look for a new name/logo after the sale is
completed. The Crafts Group employs 137 people in offices in Golden,
CO and Bluffdale, UT.
Sandler is a New York investment company which owns a number of
media properties, including cable television companies, movie
theaters, and Discover magazine. Visit http://www.sandlercap.comwww.sandlercap.com.
MICHAELS STOCK OPTIONS UNDER SCRUTINY
Michaels announced on Friday that it received a grand jury
subpoena from a U.S. District Court in New York requesting documents
relating to stock-option grants from 1996 to the present. On
Thursday the company said it had received a letter from the
Securities and Exchange Commission asking it to preserve documents
regarding stock-option grants from 1990 to the present. No details
were provided regarding the options or the execs who received them.
Michaels had already launched an internal review of its options
policy and had announced it had understated approximately $60
million in compensation during a period between 1990 and 2001. The
difference stems from stock option awards that came with effective
dates that preceded the approved dates.
The company said in an SEC filing that it did not believe it
would need to restate any financial results, "but additional
information may become available which could cause the current
estimate of potential unrecorded compensation to change
materially."
The internal review was undertaken when the Wall Street Journal
recently published a study of various public companies such as
Monster.com, the Internet job-search company, that appeared to have
awarded stock options just before the stock price rose.
Stock options give execs the opportunity to earn more money
if the company's share price rises. They are usually awarded at the
stock's value on the date the company board approves it. For
example, a company board might grant an exec options for 10,000
shares at $10 each on July 1. If the stock later rises to $20/share,
the exec can buy the 10,000 shares at $10 and immediately sell them
for $20. The exec's profit: $100,000. If the options were backdated
to a time when the stock was $5/share, the exec makes even more.
Backdating options is not illegal, per se, the Securities and
Exchange Commission ruled, but it could be if there wasn't proper
disclosure to investors or if the options weren't accounted for
properly, the Associated Press reported.
However, Dow Jones News reported Michaels also announced it was
facing two "shareholder derivative" lawsuits regarding the
option-granting program, charging that Michaels board "is
guilty of breach of fiduciary duty, abuse of control, gross
mismanagement, waste of corporate assets, and unjust enrichment
because of its authorization of the options grants."
N.Y. TIMES
: DIGITAL SCRAPBOOKING IS THE
FUTURE
The June 7 edition of the New York Times included an
extensive report on scrapbookers switching to computer scrapbooking.
"... the main action is on the digital side ..., which is the
fastest-growing segment of scrapbooking, attracting novices as well
as the most experienced compilers." Among the highlights of the
article:
1. A key motivation for the change is time. Jeffrey
Housenbold, CEO of the online photo service Shutterfly, said 83% of
scrapbookers said they had not finished a scrapbook in the past
year. "It takes too much time." (Shutterfly also offers a
variety of scrapbook products and services. Visit www.shutterfly.com.)
A consumer who switched to digital, Claudine Jackson, an optometrist
and mother of two in Carlisle, PA, told the Times, "When
I get a half-hour, I have to move quickly. It would take that long
just to get my materials out."
2. Some paper companies have created CDs with digital
versions of their paper designs, and sites such as www.shabbyprincess.com
and www.twopeasinabucket.com
offer downloads of fonts and digital versions of embellishments.
3. April Anderton, founding editor of Digital
Scrapbooking magazine, said computer scrapbooking is enticing
women to buy serious computers and software. As a result, companies
such as HP and Epson (wide-format printers), Adobe (Photoshop), and
Wacom (digital writing tablets www.wacom.com)
are creating specific products and marketing them directly to
scrapbookers. Lucidiom (www.lucidiom.com)
has created a photo kiosk for scrapbook retailers and HP even offers
software Creative Scrapbook Assistant for under $30.
Visit http://h71036.www7.hp.com/hho/cache/119531-0-0-225-121.html.
SCRAPBOOKING AND RELIGION
Reminders of Faith is sponsoring a unique scrapbook event, A
Journey of Faith: A Weekend to Inspire, Sept. 21-23 in
Nashville. Attendees will spend a weekend "learning various new
ways to remember and document God's faithfulness in your life. You
will enjoy a time of fellowship and be inspired through seminars,
worship, classes, and speakers."
"Our goal continues to be to educate and inspire our
consumers to leave behind the stories of how God has been working in
their lives and we do this through inspiration writing, speaking and
communications," says President Sandra Joseph.
Sponsoring companies include Accucut, me & my BIG
ideas, Colorbok, Memories in Uniform, Forever
Yours, and Scrapmates. For more information, visit www.remindersoffaith.com/web/pageid/34550/pages.asp.
(Comment: church groups could be an excellent venue to
promote your store and introduce it to new consumers.)
KID'S CRAFTS: HIGH TECH ... OR NOT?
Parents by the millions have called on their children to help
them use computers, DVD players, VCRs, iPods and other marvels of
the digital age. But what do kids want when they want to create
high tech or low tech?
On June 8 the New York Times published a report on the
growing trend of technology and crafts for kids. It highlighted the PicoCricket
Kit.
"At first blush, the PicoCricket Kit resembles a
plastic box of arts and crafts supplies, crammed with colored felt,
pipe cleaners, cotton, and Styrofoam balls. But this is a
craft kit for the digital age. It includes electronic sensors,
motors, sound boxes, connecting cables, and a palm-size,
battery-powered, programmable computer. By combining the traditional
materials with high-tech ones, children as young as 9 can invent
interactive jewelry, fanciful creatures that dance, musical
sculptures, and more."
The Times said a kid could make a cat and program it to
purr when someone pets it or create a birthday cake that is
programmed to play a song when someone blows out the candles.
On the other hand, a recent report in TD Monthly interviewed
craft and toy manufacturers who disagreed with the Times.
Moshe Neurath, President of Hygloss, said the ideal product
is "something which the end user, the teacher or consumer will
use, enjoy and end up with a nice project without too much
work."
The article also quoted Leslie Selig, Marketing Director at Darice,
who explained, "... our most popular products are no-tech,
hands-on things that use kids imaginations and creativity. Things
that involve the kids with the parents, which let kids be kids. Its
a total return to basics, combining household items with our
products, merging art and science. Kids getting their hands gooey
and creating their own toys, using their own imaginations."
(Comment: What do you think will appeal to kids high
tech, low tech, or a combination of both? Email your thoughts to CLN
at mike@clnonline.com.)
VENDORS COME, GO, AND CHANGE
1. Advantus and Ashley Smith will discontinue the Magic
Scraps line beginning Jan. 1 a mutual decision by Ashley, Magic
Scraps' founder, and Advantus President Kevin Carpenter.
Advantus will continue to sell Magic Scraps Scrappy Glue and Scrappy
Tape; the remaining Magic Scraps inventory will be
available for sale while supplies last.
"Advantus is committed to our craft and hobby
division," Carpenter said. "At this time we find it
necessary to focus our resources on the Cropper Hopper and Heidi
Swapp brands. With the pending addition of two new major brands
to be revealed at CHA Winter 2007, we made the difficult
decision to discontinue Magic Scraps."
Smith added, "I'm thankful for the experience that Advantus
has given me, but I'm an entrepreneur at heart and happiest when I'm
running my own business." She will be launching a new digital
scrapbook venture, Polka Dot Potato (www.polkadotpotato.com.)
2. Kim Luty has decided to shut down her wonderful Same
Differences scrapbook company. There's an inventory reduction
sale; visit http://samediff.typepad.com/samediff_shopping
and Kim's blog at http://samediff.typepad.com.
3. Testor is now part of the Rust-Oleum companies.
It will remain an independent division and will keep its
manufacturing facility and sales office in Rockford, IL. The craft
and home dec lines include Testors, Aztek, Floquil,
Polly S, Pactra, and others.
4. Forster, the well known wood product company, is now
part of Loew-Cornell. Both companies are owned by Jarden
Corp., a public company traded on the NY stock exchange under
the symbol, JAH. Forster produces craft sticks, dowels, Woodsie
shapes, and other wood products.
THE INDUSTRY FORUM EXPLAINED
Ever worry that you're the only business with a particular
problem? Ever wanted to compare notes with others about serious
issues facing your business and therefore the entire industry?
Attendees at the CHA Summer Show July 21-23 will get that
chance and a free breakfast, too.
Sunday morning, July 21, attendees with free tickets will eat a
buffet breakfast, and while they're eating, they will hear six
speakers, each explaining briefly a particular issue facing many
businesses. After eating, attendees will break into discussion
groups devoted to each issue. Each table will have a discussion
leader to get the conversation going. There will be no attempt to
provide 100%-accurate, all-encompassing solutions. Rather, the goal
is to provide an atmosphere conducive to help everyone in the
industry compare notes, learn from each other, and realize they are
not alone.
The topics: "How to finance the growth of your
business" ... "How to recognize and capitalize on trends
as they relate to your business" ... "How to develop
strategies to differentiate and grow your business" ...
"How to understand and inspire your customers" ...
"How to best manage the ups and downs of the market cycle"
... "How the industry can help independents survive and
prosper."
The Forum is free but tickets are required (so the staff knows
how much food to order). Visit www.chashow.org.
WHERE TO FIND LISTS OF RETAILERS
CLN is asked periodically where vendors can find a list of
industry retailers. There is no master list, and if one existed, it
would be out of date as soon as it was published, given the number
of stores opening and closing. However, here are some suggestions:
1. Trade show exhibitors often have the opportunity to
purchase a show's attendee list after the show closes. Contact the
show sponsors.
2. Many vendors include on their websites the names and
addresses of stores that sell their products. It could be very time
consuming to find and collate the names from various sites, but if
you want a list badly enough....
3. Consider exchanging customer lists with other vendors.
4. Trade magazines do not rent their circulation lists,
but may on occasion do a mailing for an advertiser. And, of course,
there's always advertising and creating a list from the reader
response cards.
5. Some trade associations offer its members a membership
directory, often divided by category, such as "retailers."
Whatever the size/extent of your customer list, a good way to
keep it "clean" is to do an annual, simple, first-class
mailing. That way you can cull the names of stores whose letters
were returned by the Post Office.
RANDOM NOTES, RANDOM THOUGHTS
1. Retailers, it's toward the end of the day and there are
no customers in your store. Vendors, the trade show's almost over
and there are no buyers in sight. Been tempted to close your doors
or start tearing down your booth? I learned that lesson last week.
My wife Barbara, the new jewelry-making maven, and I were selling
her creations at a farmer's market in Peoria, IL last Saturday. We
had had a good morning, the market was closing in five minutes, and
so I started putting away the unsold jewelry. "Wait! Don't put
that away; I want my girlfriend to see it," came a voice from
behind me.
I turned and sure enough, a woman was bringing her friend over to
our display. The friend bought Barbara's most expensive necklace
$350.
2. Retailers thinking of attending the Memory Trends show
in Las Vegas in October may want to check the site, www.memorytrends.com,
and check out the prices.
MISCELLANEOUS NEWS PEOPLE
A.C. MOORE. A.C. Moore also announced that Michael Joyce
has been appointed non-executive Chair of the board of directors. He
succeeds William Kaplan, who is retiring as Chair but will remain on
the board. Joyce has served on the board since June 2004 after
retiring as a partner in the public accounting firm Deloitte ... The
company also announced that Joseph Coradino joined the board.
Coradino is a member of the board of trustees and Chair of
Pennsylvania Real Estate Investment Trust. He's currently serving as
President of PREIT Services and PREIT-Rubin, management affiliates
of PREIT that manage retail real estate.
HANCOCK. Named Gail Moore as Sr. VP/Chief Merchandising
Officer, in charge of strategy, assortment planning, sourcing, and
private label product development. She reports to CEO Jane Aggers.
Moore had been Sr. VP, Divisional Merchandise Manager, for Fred's.
She had also worked at Dollar General and Belk department stores.
According to a filing with the Securities and Exchange Commission,
Moore receives a base salary of $190,000/year, is eligible to
participate in the Hancock's bonus, long term restricted stock, and
401(k) plans. She also received 25,000 shares of restricted common
stock which will vest in five equal annual installments, and
received stock options to purchase 50,000 shares of common stock
which will vest in four equal annual installments.
C&T. C&T Publishing named Mary Wruck as Product
Development Manager. She had worked for MacPhersons and Savoir-Faire.
MISCELLANEOUS NEWS
ACQUISITIONS. Reuters reported two more investment
companies, Leonard Green and Hellman & Friedman, have joined
together to consider an offer for Michaels.
NUMBERS. Hancock reported that corrections for an
accounting error related to pension expense and benefit obligations
will result in non-cash charges over prior years, estimating the
cumulative after-tax impact from 1988 through 2004 is about $1.2
million, or 6 cents/share. The company said recent quarterly and
fiscal year reports will need to be restated.
SHOWS. Exhibit square footage for the CHA Summer
Show has already surpassed the last several summer shows and hotel
bookings are up 16% over last years total. The CHA show is July
21-23 in Rosemont, IL. Visit www.chashow.org.
JOBS. The Society of Decorative Painters board of
directors is accepting resumes for an Executive Director. Send
inquiries/resumes to Darla Foreman, President, SDP, 373 N. McLean
Blvd., Wichita, KS 67203-5968.
MAGAZINE. SoHo Publishing has launched Adorn, a
quarterly "geared toward the growing numbers of hip, young
crafters determined to give their clothing, furnishings, and
accessories a creative, one-of-a-kind spin." For editorial,
call Christina Batch at 212-937-2589 or email christina@sohopublishing.com;
for advertising, call Dorreen Connors at 212-937-2554.
TV. Duncan and the entire industry received a wonderful
3.5-minute plug recently on CNBC. Among other things, it plugged the
embellished clothing worn by American Idol contestants.
LAWSUIT. QVC and the Home Shopping Network are
fighting in in a Philadelphia courtroom over the use of the phrase,
"Christmas in July." (Comment: Some craft stores
have been having "Christmas in July" events for decades.)
KNITTING. The Professional Knitwear Designers Guild has
become the Assn. of Knitwear Designers (AKD) dedicated to establishing and
maintaining a standard of excellence for knitwear designers. To
partner with a designer member or receive info about accreditation
visit www.knitwear-designers.org
or email President Diane Zangl at stitchwi@dotnet.com.
YARN. A recent issue of Family Circle highlighted Afghans
for Afghans, a group that, like Warm Up America!, creates
afghans from donated squares. Ann Shayne and Kay Gardiner proposed
the idea for the program on their blog, www.masondixonknitting.com,
and thus far have received 1,000+ squares and made 25+ blankets.
Visit www.afghansforafghans.org.
IMPORTS. Although China has made some progress in its
efforts to enforce intellectual property rights, the country still
has "a long way to go," U.S. officials said at a June 7
hearing of the U.S.-China Economic and Security Review Commission,
according to a U.S. State Department report ... The Times/Post News
Service reported the shipping rates to some U.S. ports have fallen,
due to a cooling-off of international trade and a slow-down in
demand by countries beset by higher gas prices and inflation.
QUOTATION. "... the people now running some of the
country's largest big-box specialty chains are not merchants who
have worked their way up the ranks they're bankers. And as such,
they don't always place the same value on the fundamental building
blocks of organic retailing, such as marketing, advertising, store
growth, associate development, and community relations, to name just
a few." Tim Craig (DSN Retailing Today)
TOYS. Inspired by the recall of Rose Art's Magnetix
line and the subsequent lawsuits claiming children were injured or
killed when they swallowed magnets, the toy committee of the
international standard-setting organization, ASTM Int., met to
discuss new warning labels, a performance test, or limiting the
strength of magnets, the Washington Post reported.
QUOTATION. "I'm part of the [Baby Boomer] generation
that said it wanted to change the world, and it did. We let the
40-hour workweek morph into the 60-hour workweek and even the
80-hour workweek." Anna Quindlen (Newsweek)
QUOTATION. "It is time to get creative. Let's start
some new craft or vehicle dιcor
projects. How about some designs for redecorating SUV's into
spare rooms or mother-in-law quarters? Since gas is sucking up the
discretionary $'s, our industry needs to offer some alternatives for
these soon-to-be-disposable vehicles." Industry Retailer
SIGN OF THE TIMES. Canon announced it will stop developing
new single-lens reflex film cameras as more consumers switch to
digital. Nikon already announced it would stop making seven
of its nine film cameras.
TV. The 14th series of Needle Arts Studio with Shay
Pendray produced by KS Inc. uplinks July 23. Visit www.shaypendray.com.
It's sponsored in part by Coats & Clark, DMC, and The
National Needlearts Assn ... Cutter Productions will premier
new series of For Your Home and Glass with Vicki Payne in
July.
CORRECTION. In our last issue we mentioned Reflections of
Faith, a scrapbook vendor doing well in the Christian bookstore
market. It should have been Reminders of Faith. Visit www.remindersoffaith.com.
CONDOLENCES. To the family of Machiko Ito of AITOH,
who passed away after a four-year battle with ovarian cancer. I lieu
of memories, send donations to the UCSF Foundation, Gynecology
Oncology, UCSF, Box 0248, San Francisco, CA 94143-0248.
THE CREATIVE NETWORK: JOB OPENINGS
To read the current job listings by the only personnel
recruitment firm specializing in our industry, click on Jobs in the
left-hand column or click HERE.
THE CLN RETAIL INDEX
A. C. Moore (ACMR). Last*: 15.59 ... Change**: -2.48
Hancock Fabrics (HKF). Last*: 3.18 ... Change**: -0.29
Jo-Ann Stores (JAS). Last*: 14.72 ... Change**: -1.72
Michaels (MIK). Last*: 37.93 ... Change**: -1.02
Wal-Mart (WMT). Last*: 48.31 ... Change**: +0.48
CLN Retail Index. Last*: 119.73 ... Change**: -4.0%
Dow Jones Index. Last*: 11,014.56 ... Change**: -2.1%
*June 16 ** from June 2 Prices are exclusive of dividends
THE "JOYS" OF HIGH TECH
As the world, including scrapbooking and even kids crafts,
becomes more high tech, the last straw for columnist Ellen Goodman
of the Boston Globe was when a friend bought a new toothbrush
that came with an instructional DVD. Apparently it wasn't a mere
toothbrush but an IntelliClean System another example of
modern conveniences offering far more features than we want,
features that merely mystify, confound, and frustrate us.
"All of our daily lives have become more complicated.
Americans moonlight in the self-service economy pumping our own
overpriced gas, checking out our own groceries, printing our own
pictures. Not to mention picking our own Medicare prescription plans
and 401(k)s.
"But faced with gadgets test-marketed on 14-year-olds,"
Goodman wrote, "we now blame ourselves for being tech-unsavvy
rather than blaming tech for being user-unfriendly."
A case in point: a few years ago my watchband broke. My wife,
Barbara, was going shopping and volunteered to buy a new one. She
returned with not a watchband but a new watch that was cheaper than
any watchband she could find.
The watch came with a 40-page instruction book. I struggled with
the watch for an hour setting the correct time and date. Then I gave
up, because that was all I wanted from a watch.
A few months later Barbara and I accompanied my sainted Aunt
Virginia to Midnight Mass on Christmas Eve. At the Consecration, the
most reverent moment in the Catholic Mass, my watch started playing
"Jingle Bells," and I didn't know how to turn it off.
REMINDERS
1. If you want a hard-copy of this issue, click on
"Printer Friendly version."
2. If your company is a paid subscriber, everyone in the main
office is welcome to register, free. Just click on "Work for a
paid subscriber? Click Here to register."
3. If you ever have trouble with your password, click on
"Trouble with your password" in the right-hand column of
the main page. The computer will then email the correct information
to you.
4. Creative Leisure News is published the first and third Mondays of each
month. Your next issue will be Monday, July 3.
xxx