COMMENTARY: Thought
Provoking, not Definitive
The last issue of CLN generated more comments on more
subjects than any previous issue. My favorite comment, published
below, is from Larry Olliges who said the issue provided "lots
of food for thought."
That's really all I'm trying to do: give you food for thought
about your business and your industry. And not just by ranting and
raving on my own, but by publishing thoughtful comments from readers
in every corner of the industry. You'll find lots of those comments
in this issue and in the columns. (And I hope they will inspire you
to add your thoughts to the discussions.)
On the other hand, a well meaning subscriber said CLN was
the "Bible" of the industry. Uh oh. I'm not near smart
enough, or blessed enough, for CLN to be considered THE word
on the industry. After all, Matthew, Mark, Luke, and Hartnett
doesn't sound right to me.
NEW COLUMNS THIS ISSUE
Business-Wise. Thoughtful responses on the decline of the
"Smiling Bunny Syndrome" that has dominated craft design
for decades.
Designing
Perspectives. Advice on how designers can cope with
the changing nature of our industry and its design trends.
Memory Paper &
Stamp. Retailer Lisa Kanak on how to
increase the size of the scrapbook pie.
Kate's
Collage. An excerpt from a wonderful new book, Craft
To Heal: Soothing Your Soul with Sewing, Painting, and Other
Pastimes.
Scene &
Heard. A report on a very disappointing trade
show sponsored by the Home Sewing Assn. in Las Vegas.
Tech Topics. How do we attract the techno-savvy younger
generation to crafts? Some thoughtful comments.
Note. If you surf to a column and it's an "old"
column, click the "Refresh" or "Reload" button
of your browser.
TAKE THE CLN POLL: THE
STATE OF SCRAPBOOKING
Retailers: Is consumer interest up, down, or hard to gauge
because so many retailers are dividing the pie?
Vendors: Are your sales to independents up or down due to
more/fewer independents ordering or gaining/losing market share to
competitors?
To vote, click on Industry Polls in the right-hand column, or
click HERE.
CLN
POLL: WHO'S GOING TO
WHICH SHOW(S)?
Retailers. 57.1% plan to attend the CHA Summer Show (Chicago,
July), while 38% will not attend and 4.8% are undecided. 65% plan to
attend Memory Trends (Las Vegas, Oct.) while 25% will stay away and
10% are undecided. 76.2% plan to attend the CHA Winter Show (Las
Vegas, Feb.), while 4.8% will not and 19% have not decided.
Vendors. 64.3% will exhibit at the CHA Summer Show; 33.3%
will not and 2.4% remain undecided. 53.9% will exhibit at Memory
Trends; 33.3% will not and 12.8% are undecided. 90% will exhibit at
the CHA Winter Show; 2.5% will not and 7.5% are undecided.
For more info: www.chasummershow.com
... www.memorytrends.com
... www.chashow.org.
FIRST-QUARTER STOCK REPORT
The good news: Thanks to Michaels, CLN's Retail Index outperformed
the Dow in the first quarter of 2005; the bad news: almost everyone
else was negative. CLN's Retail Index slipped 0.4% in the first
quarter, while the Dow dropped -2.6%. The members of the CLN
Index: Michaels, +21.2% ... Jo-Ann's, +2.1% ... Wal-Mart, -5.0%
... A.C. Moore, -7.1% ... Hancock, -28.4%. (Rag Shops is no longer a
publicly traded company.)
Martha Stewart may have caused a stir with her poncho, but her
company's stock fell 22.2%. Industry publisher Primedia had its best
quarter in recent memory, rising 15.1%, while Meredith, another
public publisher with industry related magazines, fell 13.8%. Target
was down 3.6%, but once again outperformed Wal-Mart.
YARN RESEARCH ATTRACTS MEDIA
ATTENTION
USA Today used data from the new research study by the Craft
Yarn Council of America as its "Snapshot" on the front
page of the Life section of its 3/28 issue. The 3/30 issue of the New
York Times also referred to the study. Among the highlights of
the survey:
1. Women ages 25-34 account for 33% of the 53 million
American women who know how to knit or crochet. The size of that age
group increased more than 150% since 2002.
2. Yarn purchasers made an average of 15.3 projects last
year, unchanged from 2002, so the sales growth is coming from
attracting consumers new to knitting and crochet.
3. The majority of yarn consumers, 37%, spend $4-$7 per
skein; 35% spend $2-$4/skein; 11% spend $7-$10/skein.
4. Throws remain the most popular project (53% of yarn
consumers), followed by baby blankets (42%), scarves (36%),
hats/gloves, 13%.
WAL-MART FORMER VICE CHAIR
RESIGNS
Wal-Mart's former vice chair Thomas Coughlin resigned as a
director due to a company investigation into unauthorized use of
corporate gift cards and personal reimbursements that has also been
reported to federal prosecutors, Reuters reported. Coughlin joined
Wal-Mart in 1978 and had once been President/CEO of the company's
stores division.
Wal-Mart also reported to the Securities and Exchange Commission
that the money involved ranged from $100,000 to $500,000, and the
company had also fired three employees, include a vice president.
The employees were not named.
"The investigation relates to personal reimbursements,
payment of third-party invoices, and the use of company gift
cards," Wal-Mart said in a statement. "There will be no
adverse financial impact to the company in connection with this
matter."
In December Wal-Mart had announced Coughlin's retirement as vice
chair, but that he would remain on the board until the annual
shareholder meeting in June.
In February, Bentonville announced it was naming its new public
library after Coughlin; the Walton Family Foundation and Wal-Mart
Sam's Club Foundation had donated $4 million to the project. When
Coughlin resigned as vice chair he had agreed to a strict clause
forbidding him from speaking to any employees of competitors (e.g.
Target) in order for him to remain eligible for various stock
options and bonuses. No word on the library name or the stock
options.
(Comment: Hard to believe Coughlin would be stealing from
the company. Since Dec. 30, Coughlin has directly or indirectly sold
712,855 shares of Wal-Mart stock for $21,783, 256, according to
Vickers Stock Research Corp.)
F+W/KRAUSE FOR SALE
F+W Publications is for sale for $550 million - $650 million,
the Wall Street Journal reported. F+W publishes a variety of
industry-related books and magazines, including Memory Makers;
a couple of years ago F+W bought Krause Publications, which
publishes CNA.
F+W's chair, Bill Reilly, paid $130 million for F+W in March,
2002, according to American City Business Journals, and later bought
Krause Publications. Reilly is a co-founder and former CEO of Primedia,
which publishes Creating Keepsakes, Craftrends, and
other industry publications. He is the only person in industry
history who has owned both trade magazines, Craftrends and CNA,
although not at the same time. Meredith, also a publisher of
industry related magazines, is a potential buyer, the Wall Street
Journal reported. The Wall Street Journal cited sources
predicting F+W could fetch 11-13 times its 2004 earnings before
interest, taxes, depreciation and amortization, which were $50
million. Last year, F+W's revenue was about $260 million, the Wall
Street Journal reported.
OUTSOURCING JOBS = LOUSY
MORALE
Here's a sign of the times. One of the most well known companies
in our industry is moving all its manufacturing to China. You can
imagine the effect on the U.S. employees' morale. What you might not
imagine, though, is what one employee did about it.
To save money, the company, says one employee, "no longer
prints catalog sheets or sales materials, instead placing them on
CD-ROM. But that wasn't as perfect a solution as they hoped.
"A begrudged employee inserted his own thoughts about the
situation on the 2005 Catalog Sheets disc handed out at CHA.
(To hear the comments, one must turn up the volume, insert the CD,
and hold down the ALT and SHIFT keys until the loading message
disappears.)
Nothing vulgar or crude mind you, just a little auditory message
.... Even though the company had no idea the message was on the CD,
the [employee] was let go anyway right after CHA."
MISCELLANEOUS NEWS: RETAIL
MICHAELS. reported its same-store sales for the first quarter
are tracking ahead of plan and execs now expect same-store sales to
rise 5% - 7%, rather than the initial prediction of 3% - 5%. That
should result in diluted earnings/share for the quarter to increase
29% - 38% to $0.27 - $0.29. CEO/President Michael Rouleau attributed
the improvement to increased customer traffic and higher
transactions. He said the top departments are yarn, scrapbooking,
general crafts, and kid's crafts and the top regions are the
Pacific, Southeast, and Central zones.
STOCK. After the Michaels announcement, Southwest
Securities raised Michaels to Strong Buy and BB&T Capital
Markets upgraded Michaels to Buy.
TARGET. Has expanded its scrapbooking offerings, at least in
the larger stores. A recent thread on the Two Peas message board was
filled with excited scrappers planning to rush out to their local
Target.
MERGERS. The Kmart/Sears deal is complete: the Sears
Holding Corp. Board Chair Edward Lampert says 400 Kmarts will be
converted to the new mid-sized Sears Essential concept, but there
won't be numerous store closings, the Associated Press reported. But
there will be cuts in wages and benefits, the Detroit Free Press reported.
Three days later the company announced 250 layoffs at the
headquarters.
DUCKWALL-ALCO. Named Bruce Dale as President/CEO. Dale was
briefly the head of the now defunct Frank's Nursery, and
before that worked for Michaels for 10 years, eight of them
as president of the Aaron Bros. division.
GARDEN RIDGE. The bankruptcy court approved the disclosure
statement, so creditors will receive the disclosure statement,
reorganization plan, and ballots this month ... Reported a 6%
increase in February same-store sales and an 8-point increase in
product gross margin.
DOLLAR STORES. According to the consulting firm, Retail
Forward, dollar stores had 15,000+ outlets in 2003, with 8,000 more
projected to open by 2008. Among the best selling items are party
goods, toys, stationery, and candles. This type of store has grown,
in part, because it's attracting middle-class consumers who can't
pass up a bargain, not just lower-income consumers, Retail Forward
stated.
QUOTATION. "In a real sense, retailers are abdicating
their responsibility when they rely too heavily on manufacturers to
figure out consumers and come up with new ways to meet their needs.
In the end, that’s what the retailing business is all about."
– Jeffrey Woldt, Mass Market Retailers (3/7/05 edition)
QUOTATION. "Michaels will never have a 'perfect
store' until they improve their relationships with their
vendors." – Industry manufacturer
ONLINE SCRAPBOOKS: WILL THEY
HELP OR HURT?
Recently CLN exchanged emails with Charlotte Roby, who
owns Roby's Photo Shop and Scrapbook store, a one-hour
digital lab/scrapbook store in Damascus, MD that also offers photo
restorations and custom framing. We told Charlotte we were concerned
about online scrapbooks which enable consumers to "scrap"
completely online without spending a penny on the industry's
scrapbook supplies.
Charlotte's answer: "The only reason I don't think that
digital scrapbooks online will last is because our technology keeps
changing. Remember floppy disks? It is only a matter of time before
we are on to the next storage thing. Also, remember how everyone
said online books were going to replace regular ones? Nothing will
ever replace the feeling of a book on your lap as you sit with your
child or parent, going over memories!" (To learn about
Charlotte's operation, visit www.robysphotoshop.com.)
On the other hand, consumers can put their scrapbook online so
they can share it with friends and relatives around the world,
something they can't do with a "hard-copy" scrapbook.
So, will online scrapbooks hurt our industry? Or encourage
consumers to make both types, and therefore ultimately help our
industry? Email your thoughts to mike@clnonline.com.
EMAIL: ADJUST TO CHANGE OR
...?
Wow! Way too much info in this week's newsletter. Lots of food
for thought.
I think we are obviously in an era for change in this industry,
and we certainly have to figure out how to attract the 30-and-under
crowd.
I think part of the reason knitting is so popular, especially
knitting scarves and hats (the young knitters like to knit hats), is
the fact they have lots of yarn to choose from, but they do not need
a pattern. Once they learn to knit, they can just do their own
thing. One of the new yarn shops in Louisville is owned by a young
couple and is in a neighborhood that caters to the young 16 to 30
year old crowd.
Us old craft people have got to accept change or we will not
survive until the next generation. This is not the craft industry of
the 1980's or 1990's; I'm not even sure it is the industry of last
year. – Larry Olliges, Dee's Crafts, Louisville, KY.
RANDOM NOTES, RANDOM THOUGHTS
1. My cable company doesn't provide the Style Network, so I
haven't seen the new series, Craft Corner Deathmatch. But
judging from reports from CLN subscribers, it sounds
unrelentingly stupid and insulting to true crafters. And does the
show have to end with a host saying, "Remember, it's cheaper
and easier to just buy stuff"?
2. A quick look at CLN's subscriber list would
eliminate any doubt that our industry is truly international. CLN
is now read by subscribers in 19 countries on six continents.
NEWS: GENERAL ECONOMY
HEALTH CARE. The U.S. House Education and Workforce Committee
passed the Small Business Health Fairness Act (HR 525) which would
enable small businesses to purchase health insurance through trade
associations. The bill has 115 House sponsors from both sides of the
aisle, and President Bush said he's in favor of it, but it is
expected to face a tough fight in the Senate. To learn more, visit www.ahpsnow.com.
TAXES. Refund season may not be as good for retailers as once
thought. Almost 148 million taxpayers expect a refund this season,
but 49% plan to use the money to pay down debt and 39% hope to put
at least some of it in savings, according to new research by the
National Retail Federation. A previous NRF study indicated consumers
spent almost $1 billion less this Easter, which was the earliest
(and therefore coldest) Easter in 15 years.
LAW. By a 5-3 vote, the U.S. Supreme Court has held that age
bias against workers over 40 is illegal under the Age Discrimination
in Employment Act, even if it is unintentional.
NEWS: TRADE SHOWS
CHA SUMMER SHOW. It's July 15-17, with education starting the
14th. It will feature 580+ exhibitors in 1,400+ booths. Educational
highlights include Susan Inglis on the key elements of marketing and
use of the media, Retail Doctor Bob Phibbs on overcoming the
competition, Mark Mayberry on attracting top-notch employees, and
buying and selling on eBay. There will also be at least 10
mega-workshops and 61 technique classes. CHA members will receive
the Buyer Registration Kit later this month. Visit www.chasummershow.com.
PAPER. Paperworld USA, the new show sponsored by SHOPA
and the sponsors of the huge paper shows in Germany and Spain, will
be Nov. 9-11 in Las Vegas. visit www.paperworld-usa.com.
NEEDLEWORK. The Buyer Brochure for the NeedleArts Market in
Columbus June 11-13 has been mailed, and online registration is
available for members of TNNA or INRG. Visit www.tnna.org
or www.inrg.org
or call 800-889-8662. (Comment: Judging from recent TNNA shows and
the knitting/crochet trend, look for this show to break more
attendance records.)
TOY SHOWS. The American Int. Fall Toy Show, Oct.
24-27, and the American Int. Toy Fair, Feb. 12-15, 2006. Both
in New York. Visit www.toy-tia.org.
NEWS: BOOKS AND MAGAZINES
1. DRG Publishing launched CardMaker magazine, a
bi-monthly filled with how-to's for making greeting cards,
invitations, tags, and more. Vicki Blizzard is exec editor. It will
be sold in stores and by subscription ($19.97/year). Visit www.cardmakermagazine.com.
2. Coming soon: Live. Learn. Lead To Make a Difference and
The Wal-Mart Way: The Inside Story of the Success of the World's
Largest Company, by Don Soderquist, former vp of Wal-Mart (who
gave a fascinating keynote speech a few years ago at the HIA show).
3. The American Society of Magazine Editors awarded
ReadyMade magazine a "General Excellence" nomination
for its National Magazine Awards. Launched in December 2001,
ReadyMade is a "a bi-monthly magazine for people who like to
make stuff" and is owned in part by Interweave Press.
Visit www.readymademag.com.
4. It's official. F+W has pulled the plug on its new
magazine, PaperArts.
5. TheBookStandard.com listed the top selling craft books as
of Mar. 20: #1 Stitch 'N Bitch: The Knitter's Handbook, by
Debbie Stoller (Workman Publishing); #2 Knitting for
Dummies, by Pam Allen (Wiley); and #3 Stitch 'N Bitch
Nation by Debbie Stoller (Workman).
6. Interweave Press was named the fifth fastest-growing
independent book publisher in the country by Publishers Weekly.
"The American public’s increased interest in crafts has been
the catalyst behind the explosive growth at Interweave Press over
the past three years," PW reported. Between 2002–2004,
Interweave increased net sales in its book division by 80%.
Interweave publishes 20-25 craft books annually, as well as
magazines such as Interweave Knits, Beadwork, PieceWork,
Spin-Off, Handwoven, and Fiberarts. Some of
Interweave's best sellers in the last three years have been knitting
and crochet books, with many backlist titles selling more copies in
2004 than when they were first released. The Knitter’s
Companion by Vickie Square was first published in 1996 and sold
a record 35,000 copies last year. Craft and specialty stores account
for about 46% of the company’s sales. For info, visit www.interweave.com.
MISCELLANEOUS NEWS
FOR SALE/MERGER. Craft, cross stitch, needlework and
accessory company (in business for 25+ years) seeking a merger or
sale. Company imports majority of its products and distributes to
such accounts as Wal-Mart, Jo-Ann’s, A.C. Moore, Michaels, Hobby
Lobby, Hancock; also sells to major craft distributors who sell to
independents and specialty retailers throughout the world. Excellent
listings and relationships providing tremendous opportunity for
growth. For more info, call Mike Hartnett at 309-925-5593 or email mike@clnonline.com.
PEOPLE. Richard Brown resigned as sales/marketing VP for Spinrite
and as chair of the Craft Yarn Council of America. Coats
North America President John Laurie assumes the CYCA chair.
LOOKING TO HIRE. Ellison Educational Equipment is looking for
a National Sales Director. Need not relocate; up to 80% travel.
Email resumes to humanresources@ellison.com
... Major manufacturer looking for an aggressive Sales Manager. For
details, call Mike Hartnett in confidence at 309-925-5593 or email mike@clnonline.com.
MARTHA'S PONCHO. The download # for the poncho pattern on Lion
Brand Yarn's site has now passed 350,000 ... Interweave Press
and Coats & Clark have The Freedom Poncho at www.coatsandclark.com
and www.interweave.com.
This version was designed/interpreted by Lily Chin, the official
"World's Fastest Crocheter." She appeared and showed the
pattern on the CBS Early Show.
INTERNET. The Craft & Hobby Assn. has upgraded/revamped
its website. Visit www.craftandhobby.org
to see all of the new features.
INTERNET. ScrapFriends.us, an educational and informational
scrapbooking and paper craft site, is looking for additional Review
Team members. To learn more, visit www.scrapfriends.us/review_team_call.html.
RECALL. Rose Art is voluntarily recalling its face-painting
line, Design A Face Make-Up, according to the Consumer
Product Safety Commission and the Food and Drug Administration. Rose
Art received complaints that 200+ children experienced minor adverse
reactions. No reactions lasted more than a few days. For info, call
800-272-9667, visit www.fda.gov/opscom/backgrounders/complain.html,
or email info@roseart.com.
PAINTING. The Society of Decorative Painters has a new
program, the Junior Artist Club, for kids ages 7 and up. May
28 will be Kids Day at the Annual Conference/Expo in Tampa
with free admission for attendees 15 years and under – plus free
make-it/take-its, giveaways and group art projects. For more on Kids
Day, call Teri Mott at 316-269-9300, ext. 115 or email teri@decorativepainters.org.
MEMORY. To read a fascinating discussion about scrapbooking
by professional graphic designers, visit www.designobserver.com/archives/000883.html.
BEADS. The second series of Beads, Baubles & Jewels uplinks
with PBS stations on May 11. Sponsors include Bead & Button magazine,
Fire Mountain Gems and Beads, BeadStyle magazine, Beadalon,
Westrim, Blue Moon Beads, and Pure Allure. According to a very
positive article in the Cleveland Plain Dealer on
jewelrymaking's growth, the first series is already airing on 61
stations.
QUOTATION. "I saw the mention of the Bob Ross T-shirts
in your current issue. I had to buy a 'happy clouds' shirt as soon
as I saw it; Bob Ross was part of my growing up years. Without him,
Thomas Kinkade would not be where he is today – same style,
different marketing." – PC Smart
BUSINESS PROFILE: HOUSTON ART
Houston Art is celebrating its 40th year in the arts and
crafts industry. On Nov. 22, 1965, Houston Art opened its doors as a
manufacturer and distributor of art and craft supplies. Founder Jim
Mulvey started the Mona Lisa brand of artist materials in 1968, and
the brand continues to flourish today with products such as Mona
Lisa Gold Leaf and Pink Soap.
Jim was later posthumously awarded one of the Craft &
Hobby Assn.'s highest awards for being a true pioneer of the
industry.
Since incorporating in 1965, Houston Art has witnessed many
changes in the industry and has adapted to those changes in order to
succeed in today's marketplace. Houston Art is no longer a wholesale
distributor of art and craft products.
Today the company is focused on expanding the Mona Lisa brand and
developing the Messenger Collection, a brand of children's
and adolescents' art and stationery products such as Glass Marker
and Yard Art. The newest venture is a licensing agreement
with the popular designer Rebecca Baer; the result is the Rebecca
Baer Collection of products for stamping and stenciling with
gold leaf.
The company is still managed by the founding family. Tim Mulvey
started his career with Houston Art in 1984 and became President/CEO
in 1996. John Mulvey joined in 2003 as Sales & Marketing VP
after working at Binney & Smith, manufacturer of the Crayola brand.
Although the arts and crafts industry has grown by leaps and
bounds since the mid-60's, it remains a close knit, friendly
industry, Tim says. He appreciates the loyalty of his company's
customers and vendors. "It's been a fun ride, and I look
forward to the next 40 years."
Rolodex: 10770 Moss Ridge Rd., Houston, TX 77043-1175. Call
800-272-3804 or 713-462-1086; fax 713-462-1783; email timm@houstonart.com;
visit www.houstonart.com.
Note: CLN will profile one company per issue, which will
remain online for at least a year. A Profile is a perfect way for a
new company to let itself be known to the industry, or for an
established company to enhance its reputation by showing the
industry its history, diversity of products, personnel, etc. For
more information on how your company can be profiled, call Mike
Hartnett at 309-925-5593 or email mike@clnonline.com.
THE CREATIVE NETWORK: JOB
OPENINGS
To read the current job listings, click on Jobs in the left-hand
column or click HERE.
THE CLN
RETAIL INDEX
A. C. Moore (ACMR). Last*: 26.10 ... Change**: -0.34
Hancock Fabrics (HKF). Last*: 7.57 ... Change**: +0.09
Jo-Ann Stores (JAS). Last*: 27.06 ... Change**: -1.74
Michaels (MIK). Last*: 36.00 ... Change**: -0.30
Wal-Mart (WMT). Last*: 48.99 ... Change**: -1.12
CLN Retail Index. Last*: 145.74 ... Change**: -2.5%
Dow Jones Index. Last*: 10,404.30 ... Change**: -2.1%
*April 1 ** from March 18 Prices are exclusive of dividends
HOW TO LIVEN UP YOUR PRESS
RELEASES
Want to add some punch to your press releases? Make them
memorable? Maybe adding similes, metaphors, and analogies would do
the trick. These examples, emailed by a subscriber, are from the
annual "Dark and Stormy Night" (bad writing) competition.
They are actual analogies and metaphors found in high school essays.
1. Her face was a perfect oval, like a circle that had its
two sides gently compressed by a Thigh Master.
2. His thoughts tumbled in his head, making and breaking
alliances like underpants in a dryer without Cling Free.
3. She grew on him like she was a colony of E-coli and he was
room-temperature beef.
4. She had a deep, throaty, genuine laugh, like that sound a
dog makes just before it throws up.
5. Her vocabulary was as bad as, like, whatever.
6. He was as tall as a six-foot-three-inch tree.
7. The little boat gently drifted across the pond exactly the
way a bowling ball wouldn't.
8. McBride fell 12 stories, hitting the pavement like a Hefty
bag filled with vegetable soup.
9. Her hair glistened in the rain like a nose hair after a
sneeze.
10. The hailstones leaped from the pavement, like maggots
when fried in hot grease.
11. John and Mary had never met, like two hummingbirds who
had also never met.
12. He fell for her like his heart was a mob informant and
she was the East River.
13. Even in his last years, Grandpappy had a mind like a
steel trap, only one that had been left out so long, it had rusted
shut.
14. The plan was simple, like my brother Phil. But unlike
Phil, this plan just might work.
REMINDERS
1. For more information on how your business can be the
subject of a "Business
Profile" call Mike Hartnett at 309-925-5593 or email mike@clnonline.com.
2. If you want a hard-copy of this issue, click on
"Printer Friendly version".
3. If your company is a paid subscriber, everyone in the main
office is welcome to register, free. Just click on "Current
Subscribers Click Here To Register."
4. If you want to recommend CLN to a friend, use the
"Tell Your Friends" box on the home page.
5. Creative Leisure News will return to
its regular publishing schedule of the first and third Mondays of
each month. Your next issue will be Monday, April 18.